Leaving for Brisbane
Jul. 2nd, 2005 02:40 pmOh, and because of
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
Does anyone want anything? :P
US Supreme Court rules against Grokster
Jun. 27th, 2005 11:54 pm1) it will be hard (or impossible) for file-sharing or other P2P services to use the "Google defence" (that they are nothing more than an aggregation of links and that they are not responsible for any infringing uses that people may use their service for):
"One who distributes a device with the object of promoting its use to infringe copyright ... is liable for the resulting acts of infringement by third parties using the device, regardless of the device's lawful uses," Justice David Souter wrote in the ruling.
2) the Supreme Court does not want to pass judgement on whether the industry and its existing business model should be protected (whether by legislation, judicial decree or otherwise), instead letting the lower courts decide on this issue. Given that the original judgement was in favour of Grokster et al, this seems to suggest that the lower courts may not want to punish Grokster severely or may conclude that both positions are equally untenable.
It will be interesting to see how this case unfolds, and what kind of precedent it sets for future cases and how this will affect P2P software in general. As it is, there is some evidence that the statistics the RIAA (among others) use to measure the impact of P2P are over-stated, and that CD sales are declining for reasons other than illegal file-sharing.
Edit: Someone on slashdot posted a comment containing links to the three concurring opinions here.
Also, I find this comment interesting because it raises questions about proving intent:
How are you supposed to read the minds of the developers to figure out if they "intended" to promote illegal use? Almost every designer of P2P software probably knew perfectly well that the service would be used to trade illegal copies, but they also believed that distribution of legal content is also something that would be promoted. Would it have to be "primary intent" to promote illegal use or just "secondary intent" is enough?
Things related to conscience laws
Jun. 7th, 2005 11:45 pmThe US National Constitution Center: Laws Protecting Pharmacist's Refusal
Bush vs. Choice: Take Action against Pharmacists Refusing to Fill Women's Prescriptions.
( Some quotations from the comments on the blog entry )
It seems the New England Journal of Medicine also ran several articles on this issue in November 2004, but I don't know if I'm able to read or find them.
Food for thought
May. 30th, 2005 10:53 pmWhile I've never read any of his SF books nor much else about him, I find the article and its comments interesting as you can see both sides of the argument emerge.
Thought-provoking stuff.
Mar. 25th, 2005 10:15 pm![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-community.gif)
On Transparency within the Education System
It's something that I can relate to as I've horror stories from others. However, I don't entirely agree with the second-last paragraph in the letter, as i don't necessarily think a better opposition (even if it was significantly better than the status quo) would benefit much.
Why do I say this? Most people today have grown up in an atmosphere / political culture of "government knows best", and since they've been exposed to this idea for such a long time, they've come to depend on the culture remaining the same. So if it suddenly changes (for example, when a credible opposition emerges), people can't adapt to that change and will refuse to work with the opposition.
People who leave the country because they're fed up with the situation here are free to do whatever they want, but their leaving doesn't really make the situation any better. All it does is (IMO) open them up to accusations of being opportunistic and other such name-calling, which really beneifts no one.
This kind of attitude does smack of the defeatism that the letter-writer was talking about, but I really don't know what a viable alternative could be.
Disturbing
Mar. 13th, 2005 11:47 pmUnder Bush, A New Age of Prepackaged Television (13 March 2005)
2004: The Year in Debates
Jan. 29th, 2005 12:30 amI've been procrastinating on this long enough, so I might as well post it before I forget. :P There were 3 main tournaments during the year; namely, the All-Asians 2004 (held during May at Assumption University in Thailand), Australasians 2004 (held during July at University of Technology Sydney, Australia), and Worlds 2005 (held during December at Multimedia University, Malaysia).
I went to Asians as an adjudicator, and it was not a very remarkable tournament, except that I made the break as a reserve adjudicator (which is pretty remarkable considering my lack of experience before the tournament), and the NUS teams didn't do well. However, I did manage to make friends with several debaters and adjudicators from other countries, and we had a (relatively) nice drowning of sorrows.
Australs (as I'll refer to it hereafter) was something I would consider as a learning experience. My team was fortunate to have some good adjudicators and to debate against some good teams. However, we also got some decisions which we didn't understand, and ultimately we missed the ESL break by 2 points due to an error. It was, however, a blessing in disguise (albeit not a very happy one) as I was able to fly to Brisbane to stay with my relatives there for some time and go around the city. This should be useful knowledge in case I go to Brisbane for Australs 2005. :-)
Worlds was, to put it frankly, very underwhelming. At least to me, it was pretty obvious which teams and adjudicators would make the break even if they showed up for all their rounds hung over, and which teams (and adjudicators) were there just to make up the numbers and so that the organizers could claim that every continent was represented. When a tournament seems to have beer at nearly every event (whether social or otherwise), but somehow can't seem to provide food for the opening ceremony, you have to wonder just where their priorities lie.
Yes, I'm bitter about the fact that I was a trainee adjudicator for 6 rounds, a panelist in the 7th, and then bumped completely off the tab for the 8th and 9th rounds. To be fair though, by the time of the 8th round, I was feeling extremely sick with a full-blown migraine and throwing up, so it's probably a good thing I didn't have to judge anything anyway.
Let's see what 2005 brings to the table in terms of the quality of the tournaments. Asians 2005 will be in Kuala Lumpus, Australs 2005 in Brisbane, and Worlds 2006 in Dublin (which, last time I checked, is not near Finland, Sweden or Norway.)
Birthday wishes
Dec. 30th, 2004 09:37 am![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
Tomorrow, for
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
Meanwhile, the wireless access at MMU is slow (read: worse than NUS), so I may drop out pretty often.
Leaving for Kuala Lumpur tomorrow
Dec. 27th, 2004 12:04 amI'll be going there for the World Universities Debating Championship 2005 organised by Multimedia University.
Over the next 10 days, I hope to post updates as and when possible, both on this blog and on my personal livejournal.
My first Worlds
Oct. 11th, 2004 02:24 amHowever, I'm a bit sad that some people weren't selected. I guess I'll have to remember to update my blog more often to let them know what we're up to in KL.
On the other hand, there are three people with the surname Lee in the NUS contingent. That's pretty remarkable, and shows the dominance of Lee families everywhere. =P
I blame it on the IS textbooks.
Aug. 24th, 2004 01:11 amI leave it up to you to figure out whether that was valid.
And on an unrelated note, this rocks. And so does this.
Back from Australs
Jul. 16th, 2004 08:51 amSo what happened?
- We didn't break for the main draw or ESL (not unexpected, but that doesn't make it any less disappointing)
- I took a 1.5-day trip to Brisbane and met up with my aunt/uncle/cousins there, as well as someone I knew only through MSN (*waves to MS and throws a pink fluffy flying elephant in his direction* ^_^)
- Managed to
crashdrop in on the international coffee festival (though I think I got sick as a result of being in the rain too much on that day) - I posted some pics that I've taken (without descriptions, because I'm too lazy): here
First impressions of Sydney
Jul. 3rd, 2004 04:33 pmAnd that's even with a pretty warm jacket I have, because I didn't bring along a cap (not such a big deal) or a pair of gloves (a big deal!)
Though, I'm going to buy a pair of gloves, a chapstick and a prepaid SIM card so that I can at least get around.. Need also to check on the status of my little excursion on Friday.
Handover of power in Iraq
Jun. 28th, 2004 06:46 pmWell, this opens up a whole new kettle of fish. Questions that should be asked (among others):
- what kind of influence will the US still have in Iraq?
- will they (the US) be able to maintain law and order, given the fact that the Iraqi military and police force are not at that level yet, and also given the increasing anti-US violence?
- what does this bode for the geopolitical situation and future of the Middle-East?
Australs 2004 tournament schedule
Jun. 7th, 2004 07:55 pmAnd yes, I'm going for Australs, as a debater again. ^_^ Which means I need to start reading up a *lot* more, and think of something to do while I'm not in Singapore.
Photos from Asians 2004
Jun. 5th, 2004 10:09 am/me listens to people argue over MMU and freezing. :)